Archive for the 'Uncategorized' Category

27
Apr
10

Season 03: Reflections

Season 3 was the most consistent in terms of quality so far. The subject matter, on the other hand, varied widely giving us a taste of aliens and humans, past, present, and future, and a companion carousel that didn’t exactly lend itself to depth of character.

Generally, the stories were good, but unremarkable. In fact, as I look back over the list, it’s difficult to decide which ones I think are worth mentioning, beyond The Daleks’ Master Plan. All of them are better than much of Season 2, but there really aren’t any standouts, good or bad. Part of this may have to do with the large number of missing episodes. It’s difficult to get a good feel for a story when it can’t be watched in its entirety. I mean, sure you can have an idea of the quality of the plot, but the scenery and the photography and the acting are difficult to gauge.

The companions, on the other hand are easy to gauge: generally crappy. Vicki, who stuck around for only two stories in season 3, was the stand out. She is probably my favorite companion so far. However, Steven suffered from a steady decline of characterization and Dodo never really had any characterization to decline. Neither of them developed much of a personality, although Steven shined on his own in The Massacre and Dodo had some bright spots here and there. So they could act, they just weren’t really given the chance to. We never got to know Dodo at all and her departure was, quite simply, awfully done. I have a feeling they just didn’t know what to do with her. She was supposed to be so young that had to keep her kind of naive (to a fault, some might say). But this also ruined Steven’s character because they apparently felt they had to lower his maturity level as well (see the Celestial Toymaker). The introduction of Polly and Ben at the end of the season seems promising. Ben seems to have a backbone and at least Polly’s good-looking.

By the end of the season, William Hartnell was clearly beginning to tire. The season was ridiculously long (44 episodes, running from September 1965 to July 1966). And the role he was playing was starting to tire as well. He was increasingly out of place amongst the youthful companions, and it’s not surprising that he only lasts a couple of stories with the hip Londoners Polly and Ben. The grandfather role he played with Susan and Vicki disappeared almost immediately. Dodo’s lack of development may have been in part due to this change in the Doctor. Overall, I have enjoyed Hartnell. Of course, I have no other Doctors to compare him to, but his wry wit and strong general acting have been worth continuing this journey. We’ll see how his forthcoming departure goes.

The upcoming fourth season includes 9 stories, 2 of which are Dalek stories. It may be sacrilege to say this, but that might be overdoing the Daleks a bit. Remember what happened when they put both the Dalek Invasion of Earth and The Chase in the same season? There are no completely in-tact stories from Season 4, and unfortunately the Doctor Switch-Over is one of the missing.

Favorite Story: The Daleks’ Master Plan

Least Favorite Story: The Celestial Toymaker

Best Villain: The Daleks (or maybe Chen from the same story….)

Worst Villain: Wotan was groundbreaking, but not exactly engaging.

26
Apr
10

Story 027: The War Machines

Model of Wotan

The War Machines was definitely written to be a season finale. There were some groundbreaking plot points, the involvement of a main character in a plot, a (somewhat unexpected) departure, and the introduction of two new characters. So, there’s quite a bit going on.

The plot is pretty familiar to us now: a computer is put in charge of decision making and promptly decides that humans are not really necessary, beginning to systematically destroy them. We start with the arrival of the TARDIS in London sometime in the mid- to late-60s. The Doctor and Dodo land near the Post Office Tower. I had to look the tower up to learn about it. Fittingly for the story (and probably on purpose by the producers/writers), the tower was intended to be (and still is) a major telecommunications hub. They make surprisingly little mention of Steven, given Dodo’s rather emotional sendoff at the end of The Savages.

Now here is the primary weakness of this story: The Doctor and Dodo show up at the tower and are immediately given access not only to the room storing the world’s most advanced computer, Wotan, but also continuous, unquestioned access to its creators and operators. Apparently, off screen, the Doctor convinced them that he was a computer genius. Apparently in 1960s London the general hobbyist was given access to top-secret technology. It’s a good thing the Russians didn’t know that! But, given the Doctor’s access, the rest of the story was fine as far as plotting.

War Machine Attack!

Some of that plot must have been pretty original for its day. Starting with the basic idea that Wotan could communicate and control all of the other major computers in the world. This story aired in the summer of 1966. The ideas for ARPANET, the beginning of the Internet, began in 1962. However, work on the network did not begin until 1968 and I think that it was well after that the public were aware. So, either writer Ian Stuart Black was very clever or had some inside information. The Wikipedia tells me it was the idea of a technical advisor. Nice work. More on this later.

Wotan, days before taking control of the world’s computers, begins turning the people into zombies. Like in the Dalek Invasion of Earth, these are old-school zombies of the laboring type, not the later brain-eating type which I’m not sure had been popularized quite yet. This is the second time we’ve seen humans enslaved via mental manipulation. It’s not really a plot device that survive multiple uses, and I think two is about all it can handle.

Dodo with Polly and Ben

Anyway, Dodo is one of those enslaved and is instructed to bring the Doctor into the fold. Now, here’s something interesting: Wotan (who knew what TARDIS meant) referred to the Doctor as Doctor Who. This is the first time that he has been referred to as such. Until now there has been no semblance of a name. Now I know that he is never really given a proper name, but is that because he doesn’t have one? Where could Wotan have gotten the name? Perhaps he watches the show?

Of course, the Doctor cannot be zombified. Instead, he works with Polly and Ben, two friends Dodo met at a nightclub, to solve the mystery of what’s going on. Polly is zombified, but Ben (a sailor) is able find out that Wotan’s slaves are building a war machine that will keep the humans under control while Wotan takes over.

The Doctor is able to reprogram one of these War Machines and have it destroy Wotan instead. The world is saved! Dodo, meanwhile, sent to the country to recover, has decided she wants to stay in London. The Doctor is informed by Polly and Ben. The only goodbye Dodo gets is a “She sends her love.”

The Doctor is rightfully incredulous, mumbling something about taking her through time and space and that’s all the respect he gets. Seriously. There is no goodbye to Dodo whatsoever. She really got the shaft by the show’s producers here. The last we see of her, Dodo has been hypnotized. She does not even appear in the final episode (or maybe two) of the story. Instead, she’s just gone. Such poor treatment. I wonder how Jackie Lane felt about being written off the show in such a way….

The Doctor Confronts a War Machine

While I was shocked at the way Dodo was unceremoniously removed, I had a feeling she was leaving as soon as I saw they were in London. And the attention given to Polly and Ben indicated that they were going to be sticking around. They unwittingly follow the Doctor into the TARDIS just before it leaves. They seem alright. I like Ben…but then again, I liked Steven at first, too.

Now, for more groundbreaking. I’m sure this was one of the first shows to deal with computers in this way. I know that some of themes had come up prior in the Twilight Zone. In one episode, The Old Man in the Cave, a computer is left to make all major decisions for a group of humans after nuclear war. And in another episode (I forget the title), computers are put to work and eventually put the humans out of work. However, the controlling of other computers and the world generally was knew. The War Machines themselves were predecessors of the Terminator series. And the round flashing light was very similar to HAL in 2001: A Space Odyssey (1968). There is little doubt that Stanley Kubrick, who moved to England in 1962 undoubtedly saw this story of Doctor Who. Additionally, the story had a very cinematic feel with moving cameras and obstructed shots. This has since become the goal of science fiction television shows such as Fringe. They all want to look more like movies and less like television.

The apparent impact of this story is impressive. On its own, the story is pretty good, although not the best I’ve seen so far. Season 3 is over and I’ve got some reflections to share in the next couple of days. Also, the First Doctor’s time is soon coming to an end. I’m looking forward to seeing how it goes.

So long, Dodo. You got the shaft.




About These Adventures

This blog exists to document my trip through over 30 seasons of the British science fiction television show Dr. Who. Prior to beginning, I had never seen a single episode of Dr. Who and will be learning the show's mythology and experiencing it all for the first time. I began sometime in July of 2009. Hopefully it doesn't take me over 30 years to reach the end.

Enter your email address to subscribe to this blog and receive notifications of new posts by email.

Join 11 other followers

Archive Calendar

May 2017
M T W T F S S
« May    
1234567
891011121314
15161718192021
22232425262728
293031